The strategic importance of sub-cabinet appointments (2023)

First word

RECENT events have unraveled two failings in the staffing of the Ferdinand Marcos Jr. administration.

First, the failure to appoint an officer to superintend the personnel system of the new administration — a voice who could explain to the media and the public the government's personnel recruitment process and appointments.

Second, the poor performance of sub-cabinet appointments in the various departments and commissions in the executive branch.

These shortcomings are striking because it was to produce a good personnel system that the government budgets for a presidential transition process designed to produce a systematic and effective personnel recruitment system and a high quality of appointees by the president.

Get the latest news
delivered to your inbox

Sign up for The Manila Times’ daily newsletters

By signing up with an email address, I acknowledge that I have read and agree to the Terms of Service and Privacy Policy.

(Video) Board of Education - Operating Budget Work Session - 1/24/23

Because of these failings, there is today plenty of finger-pointing in the administration and much criticism in the media. Some point their fingers at the first lady, Liza Araneta-Marcos, because of her alleged interference and use of her influence in the President's decisions on appointments.

Management of personnel system

(Video) John Cena RUNS during WrestleMania #Short

It is advisable for a new president to hire or designate someone from his staff or inner circle to run the personnel operation and recruitment system in staffing the new administration.

This is a must because the transition from one administration to a new one is a complex task. A staggering number of appointments have to be made. The president's cabinet, which will be vital in the process, will have to be formed from the best and brightest available talent.

While in England and France, with their parliamentary governments, a newly elected government may change 50 to 500 appointees, the United States and the Philippines have to fill some 4,000 positions to staff their governments. The volume of applicants for the positions will be even greater, and sorting them out will require skillful screening and review.

There are career positions whose occupants are protected by law. There are positions the new administration can fill.

In the US, the House committee on the civil service publishes a list of policy and supporting positions that is known as the "plum book" because it is plum-colored, and it lists political plums that are available to the incoming administration to fill. It lists by agency, each administration incumbent by name, position and salary. It identifies whose positions a new administration can fill, and the name of political appointees who must leave.

Without this plum system, the Philippine government must face political appointees who would resist leaving office.

Even more formidable than the sheer number of positions that must be filled is the volume of demands that pour into the administration after the election. There is no quality control on this flood of applicants, and presidents need to recruit their administrations from a much broader pool than this self-selected lot. No one person can handle this volume.

James Pfiffner, the author of The Strategic Presidency, the authoritative book on the presidential transition, has written:

(Video) FCPS School Board Work Session - 1/24/23

"The importance of the timeliness of appointments to the success of a presidency should not be underestimated. In the transition of the presidency, a permanent bureaucracy takes over. Routine operations will go on without many problems, but new directions in policymaking will not be undertaken. Leadership is required but it can only be provided by the appointments of a new president. The longer the bureaucracy drifts, the longer it will be before the new president's priorities and policies can be implemented. But the necessity for speed must not stifle the need for quality of appointees, for the character of an administration and its success depend upon the quality of its officials."

Theodore Sorensen, the famous Kennedy speechwriter and adviser, underscored the personnel challenge: "Personnel is clearly the highest priority. You can't spend too much time on personnel. It is getting the right people in office. This will overcome many errors in organization and getting to know the Congress."

Different styles

Dan Fenn was hired to run President John F. Kennedy's personnel operation in 1961.

Under Fenn, the Kennedy administration setup of the White House personnel system was more systematic than it had been in the past. Fenn decided that "we were going to be in the recruitment business, not the screening business, we weren't going through the junk." Fenn's process tried to ensure that the White House would have the final authority for all major presidential appointments throughout the administration. He also tried to set up capacity for active outreach and recruiting of quality candidates who were not personal acquaintances of administration members.

Other presidents had their own personnel process for recruitment and screening. Lyndon Johnson's process was distinctive because of the overall involvement of the president in personnel operations.

In 1970, Frederic V. Malek tightened the personnel selection process by centralizing administration personnel operations in the White House. The process went beyond screening.

Under Malek, the White House personnel system developed recruitment capability and a systematic way to continue throughout the administration.

Sub-cabinet appointments

(Video) Transforming Global Access to Cancer Diagnostics: Report of the Lancet Commission on Diagnostics

In The Strategic Presidency, Pfiffner devotes a section to the discussion of sub-cabinet appointments. He wrote:

"In every administration there will be tension between White House and departments and agencies over whose wishes will prevail in naming the subordinates of the secretary or agency head.

"While the appointments are clearly the prerogative of the president who has a legitimate claim on them, it is his administration and he has to live with the consequences of his appointments in the departments and agencies. On the other hand, if agency heads are to be held responsible for managing their own organizations, they ought to have some discretion in putting together their own management teams."

Many people with White House experience tend to believe that sub-cabinet appointees should owe their primary allegiance to the president and to the cabinet member for whom they directly work. They see a danger that appointees will become more responsive to their own bureaucracies, interest groups and Congress, than to the White House. Pfiffner's observations on sub-cabinet appointments are especially relevant to our present government because in my view, the principal headaches of the Marcos administration have been caused by weak sub-cabinet appointments.

The big row over the SRA sugar importation order was the principal outcome of poor appointments of one agriculture undersecretary and the sugar board members. These appointments created themes that placed the administration in hot water, but the executive secretary at the time fueled the mess by issuing these officials with the authority to issue the sugar import order.

The current controversy over a foolish order by a deputy executive secretary stems from a sub-cabinet appointee who exceeded her authority.

As fellow Times columnist Bobi Tiglao has written, the Palace issued two days before Christmas a very anomalous order that countermanded a directive of the Department of Environment and Natural Resources' Environmental Management Bureau for a Chinese firm Yinglong Steel Corp. to stop its nickel-mining and export operations in the hometown of Zambales Gov. Hermogenes Ebdane. The same deputy executive secretary for legal affairs, Anna Liza Logan, who issued the order recalled it. Tiglao notes that the environmental issues involving Yinglong were resolved in just one day from the date when he wrote about it in his column. He suspects that neither the president nor Executive Secretary Lucas Bersamin were aware of Logan's December 23 order countermanding the EMB directive.

Logan is an unfortunate sub-cabinet appointment, and it is also doubly unfortunate that she happens to be a longtime close associate of the first lady whose name will be dragged into this controversy.

The point of course is that sub-cabinet appointments are very important, and the Marcos administration has been a little careless in the selection of appointees.

(Video) Tools for Equity in Public Spending - Virtual Recognition Event

Pfiffner concluded his discussion with the observation that it is a mistake for presidents to delegate the authority for sub-cabinet appointments to the cabinet member or department head. As Edwin Meese, who served in the Reagan transition team, contended: "The president has to decide off the bat, there should be one central control point. But while you encourage department heads to develop names, the ultimate decision is that of the president."



What role does Congress play in the appointment of the President's Cabinet? ›

The members of the President's Cabinet advise the President on all important problems he/she must face. They also lead the departments for the Executive Branch of our government. Congress must give its approval to the men and women the President appoints before they can take office.

What are the major responsibilities of Cabinet member? ›

The Cabinet's role is to advise the President on any subject he or she may require relating to the duties of each member's respective office.

What is the role of the executive departments in the President's Cabinet? ›

Under Article II of the Constitution, the President is responsible for the execution and enforcement of the laws created by Congress. Fifteen executive departments — each led by an appointed member of the President's Cabinet — carry out the day-to-day administration of the federal government.

Why are presidential cabinet appointments so important? ›

The tradition of the Cabinet dates back to the beginnings of the Presidency itself. Established in Article II, Section 2, of the Constitution, the Cabinet's role is to advise the President on any subject he may require relating to the duties of each member's respective office.

What is the process of appointing cabinet members? ›

The president nominates all federal judges in the judicial branch and specified officers in cabinet-level departments, independent agencies, the military services, the Foreign Service, and uniformed civilian services, as well as U.S. attorneys and U.S. marshals.

Does Congress approve cabinet appointments? ›

The Senate has typically granted presidents a great deal of deference in selecting members of their cabinets. The overwhelming majority of cabinet nominations have been confirmed quickly with little debate and often with simple voice votes.

What is the role of Congress in the selection of the President? ›

The voters in each State choose electors to serve in the Electoral College. The electors in each State meet to select the President and Vice President of the United States. Congress meets in joint session to count the electoral votes (unless Congress passes a law to change the date).

What role does Congress have in the appointment of federal judges quizlet? ›

The president and congress have the power to appoint and confirm appointments of judges and justices. Congress may also impeach judges, alter the origination of the federal court system, or amend the constitution. This all limits the court's power.

What was the role of Congress? ›

Congress is the legislative branch of the federal government that represents the American people and makes the nation's laws. It shares power with the executive branch, led by the president, and the judicial branch, whose highest body is the Supreme Court of the United States.


1. CDC-RFA-DP-23-0020 Informational Call
(Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC))
2. Why good leaders make you feel safe | Simon Sinek
3. Ex-Sumter daycare worker charged with hitting, throwing 5-year-old child
(News 19 WLTX)
4. Board of Chiropractic Examiners Meeting - January 20, 2023 - 2 of 2
(California Department of Consumer Affairs)
5. SNI CoP Webinar Series: Climate action at Sub-national level – The Role and Importance of MRV
(Asia LEDS Partnership)
6. Why Russia is Building an Arctic Silk Road
(The B1M)
Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Trent Wehner

Last Updated: 12/07/2022

Views: 5729

Rating: 4.6 / 5 (56 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Trent Wehner

Birthday: 1993-03-14

Address: 872 Kevin Squares, New Codyville, AK 01785-0416

Phone: +18698800304764

Job: Senior Farming Developer

Hobby: Paintball, Calligraphy, Hunting, Flying disc, Lapidary, Rafting, Inline skating

Introduction: My name is Trent Wehner, I am a talented, brainy, zealous, light, funny, gleaming, attractive person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.